Friday Round Up: Does Gender Matter Anywhere Anymore?

After my keynote at the AAUW national convention last Sunday, I overheard an attendee tell her friend about the graphic I’d used of a hot dog with “No More” written in mustard on it. I didn’t have to say a word when I put the graphic on the screen for the entire audience to start laughing at the shared awareness that I was referencing now-former NY Congressman Anthony Weiner (D-Stupid). And that by implication I was referencing the fatigue and disgust so many people feel about the seemingly unending waves of philandering politicians who thus far have been almost entirely male.

This has raised much commentary pro, con, and confused regarding the question of whether greater parity for women in politics would make things better, and that leads inevitably to the question of whether there are any inherent gender differences.

So taking a cue from No Excuses Power tool #4, EMBRACE CONTROVERSY, this controversial theme is an opportunity to have that discussion while the country is paying attention to the value (or not) of having more women in politics. (Let me stop here and invite you to share your thoughts in the comments section below, before I offer some of the most thought provoking links of the week.)

This NPR article titled “The End Of Gender” addressed the biggest picture questions and I found it great food for thought.

From Media Matters comes this analysis of a scene on the floor of the U.S. House of Representatives when 14 of the the 24 Republican women serving in the House claimed “the Republican agenda is indeed pro-women.” As the Media Matters piece points out, “The claim would have been more compelling had they not spent their first six months in the majority focusing on making abortions less accessible, changing the definition of rape, and cut funding for women’s health care.”

Being inclusive doesn't end with simply being welcoming.

Leading inclusive conversations requires a new "language."

Get my new resource to help organizations like yours not just survive, but embrace these times of change & thrive.

FREE Language of Leadership Guide Book


So what difference did it make in this case that these women are in Congress?

One guest blogpost by Jodi Lustig on my Heartfeldt Blog this week posits that gender does matter.

The Barbara Lee Family Foundation has put out a new report that suggests the public at least does trust women candidates more than males in the wake of the not just the sex scandals but also the financial meltdown and goodness knows what else. You can download it hereplease tell us whether you agree.

And finally but perhaps most importantly, look at how the U.S. Supreme Court votes came down on Wal-Mart v Dukes, the class action suit won on technicalities by the behemoth retailer and see if you think gender made any difference. This ruling was a set back not just for women but for any aggrieved group of people who don’t hold the power of financial might but might well hold the power of social right.

My friends at She Negotiates quoted me extensively in this piece about what Wal-Mart should do to embrace the controversy in a productive way as a consequence of the public discussion about the ruling. But then, you know, I always see the pony.


No Comments

  1. Kel Madison on June 24, 2011 at 10:58 am

    Can you say “Stepford Wives” anyone?

    Talk about spin — it’s one thing to talk the talk but political actions speak louder than words. How can any of the women of the House Republicans defend their agenda to the American public with a straight face? Or is this even something more insidious – can they truly believe they are helping women with their specifically woman restrictive policies?

    Carrying the pro-business flag to cover the covert actions of religiously conservative political policy is an insult to American women. If the latest actions by the SCOTUS are any indication in Wal*Mart vs. Dukes truly means if you are big enough, you can dodge doing the right thing and are above reproach.

    These two dozen women lawmakers “drank the Kool-Aid” but their poison will be the undoing of women’s rights in America if left unchecked.

  2. Gloria Feldt on June 24, 2011 at 11:37 am

    Wow, how do you really feel, Kelly? I think you’ve nailed the matter of Republican women defending the patriarchy quite well!

  3. Aletha on June 25, 2011 at 3:02 am

    Yes, political actions do speak louder than words. What I want to know is, how can anyone in government defend their agenda with a straight face? Women’s rights are being undone, slowly but surely, as the world is going to hell, slowly but surely, and it hardly seems to matter who is in power. How did these Republican women get elected to Congress? Could it have something to do with many feminists/progressives being too demoralized by Democratic treachery to bother to vote? Which is worse, an avowed enemy or an enemy who pretends to be an ally?

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.