Equal Pay Day 2011: Are Republicans in Congress Trying to Make Women “Barefoot and Pregnant” Again?

by Gloria Feldt on April 12th, 2011
in Politics, Women & Work and tagged , , , , , , ,

Check out the fair pay flash mob on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial:

Arkansas State Senator Paul Van Dalsem got a roaring laugh in 1963 at the then all-male Optimist Club when he railed at women from the American Association of University Women (AAUW) who were lobbying to improve educational opportunities. He said his home county’s solution would be to get an uppity woman an extra milk cow. “And if that’s not enough, we get her pregnant and keep her barefoot.”

Sounds quaint, doesn’t it? Not so much, though.

Fast forward please to April 11, 2011—the day designated as Equal Pay Day by the National committee on Pay Equity to call attention to the pay gap between men and women. Women currently make about 20% less than men even when the numbers are controlled for education and experience. In other words, the pay disparity does not stem from childbearing as is often assumed, but rather from deeper systemic biases that are reflected in women’s own lack of skills and confidence in negotiating for their pay and promotions.

While I provide women with many tools to advocate for themselves in No Excuses and discuss examples frequently on the 9 Ways Blog, it’s still essential to address the systemic biases that keep women metaphorically barefoot, or at least not as generously shod as men, and to remain cognizant of how those economic facts are related to women’s rights and access to the necessary health services to plan and space childbearing.

For example, this morning’s Today Show segment sensationalized a so-called “Queen Bee Syndrome.” This cultural trope that won’t go away was framed negatively toward women’s leadership styles despite career expert Marci Alboher’s astute challenge. Alboher pointed out that we don’t call it a “King Snake Syndrome” when men don’t nurture or promote their subordinates. And Dartmouth professor Ella Bell pointed out that it’s everyone’s responsibility to improve office dynamics. “It’s not about fixing women,” Bell said, “It’s about making organizations more flexible and more tolerant.”

The same cultural biases are at the root of Congressional Republicans’ attempts to eliminate Title X, the backbone of America’s family planning program, and indeed their budget priorities overall, seen here in their own chart, and analyzed by TPM for those of us whose eyes glaze over at charts.
In a nutshell, most of the cuts are on the backs of women and children. They disproportionally decimate programs and services that help women achieve economic equality, but not those that benefit the male-dominated corporate giants and the men’s historically favorite pastime: wars. The Pentagon gets an extra $5 Billion. Education, health care (including of course family planning and reproductive health care which they single out for special brutality), environmental protection are deeply slashed or eliminated. They backed off attempts to cut all funding from Title X  in the 2011 budget deal. But that’s a temporary victory at best, and at the expense of the District of Columbia’s ability to provide its own funding for abortion coverage.

Speaker of the House Republican John Boehner has warned that the knock-down, drag-out battles over the 2011 budget were just warm-ups for what’s to come when Congress takes on spending limits and then the 2012 budget. There will be many complex plays in this game of insider politics. But one thing we can count on is that budget decision rhetoric will continue to turn on funding for family planning, a flash-point being attempts to demonize the best known service provider, Planned Parenthood.

The relevance of the “barefoot and pregnant” cultural narrative remains central to an inclusive and just America because economic parity and reproductive justice are and will always be intertwined, not only in the lives of individual women but in the nation’s economic health as well. If a woman can’t decide when to have a child, she can’t reliably enter the workforce to earn income for her family’s support, and she can’t contribute her skills to economic growth.

It’s simplistic to think that giving a woman access to preventive family planning services means she’ll find a great job and suddenly get pay equality with men. Nevertheless, the fundamentals remain. For a thriving 21st century economy, America can’t afford to lose half its population’s contributions. Not surprisingly, AAUW is once again a leading force for changes in policy, this time equal pay and other workplace measures that would level the playing field for women.

The intersection between reproductive and economic justice is as seamless today as “barefoot and pregnant” was in our history, and that’s exactly why those who want to maintain the inequitable status quo fight so hard against these two essential parts of women’s equality.

Check out AAUW’s new handbook, The Simple Truth About the Gender Pay Gap,
for updated information and a state-by-state earnings comparison by gender.

Gloria Feldt is the author of No Excuses: 9 Ways Women Can Change How We Think About Power. Buy the book here. Engage Gloria for a Speech or Workshop. Tweet @GloriaFeldt and connect on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Google+ Gloria is the co-founder (with Amy Litzenberger) of Take the Lead, a new initiative to prepare and propel women to leadership parity by 2025. Find them @takeleadwomen and on Facebook.

3 Responses to Equal Pay Day 2011: Are Republicans in Congress Trying to Make Women “Barefoot and Pregnant” Again?

  1. ROGilead Republic of Gilead
    We’ll let you wear shoes MT @GloriaFeldt: Women moved beyond ‘barefoot and pregnant,’ but Republicans have agenda http://fb.me/ZL3i7JU3
    2 hours ago Favorite Undo Retweet Reply
    Jamie Boschan
    jboschan Jamie Boschan
    Equal Pay Day 2011: Are Republicans in Congress Trying to Make Women “Barefoot and Pregnant” Again? – http://goo.gl/Idr7E via @GloriaFeldt
    3 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply
    Randolph Greer
    GandolphThePoet Randolph Greer
    @GloriaFeldt ..They just want women to understand that they are women first and humans second . :):)
    3 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply
    See Jane Do (media)
    SeeJaneDo See Jane Do (media)
    RT @GloriaFeldt New post: Equal Pay Day 2011: Are Republicans in Congress Trying to Make Women “… http://bit.ly/g0plwg #equalpay
    3 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply
    WWRG Austin
    WWRG_Austin WWRG Austin
    Come meet Gloria @bookwomanaustin 4/21! RT @GloriaFeldt: New post: Equal Pay Day 2011: Are Republicans in Cong… (cont) http://deck.ly/~F5GgK
    3 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply
    John B. Hooks, IV
    JBHIVofWWRG John B. Hooks, IV
    RT @gloriafeldt: New post: Equal Pay Day 2011: Are Republicans in Congress Trying to Make Women “… http://bit.ly/g0plwg #NoExcuses…
    3 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply
    E Brown
    vajra E Brown
    RT @GloriaFeldt: New post: Equal Pay Day 2011: Are Republicans in Congress Trying to Make Women “… http://bit.ly/g0plwg #NoExcuses
    3 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply
    Thx 4 mentions! RT @GloriaFeldt: New post: #EqualPayDay 2011: R Republicans in Congress Trying 2 Make Women“… http://bit.ly/g0plwg
    3 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply
    WWRG Austin
    WWRG_Austin WWRG Austin
    RT @GloriaFeldt: Live in Austin? Join me @ Bookwoman 4 my #NoExcuses event http://ow.ly/4×776 U can use thi… (cont) http://deck.ly/~tUbYn

  2. via Facebook says:

    Rachel Payne: Why else would they want to burden women economically, control them reproductively and dictate their social freedoms?

  3. Pingback: Hilary Rosen v Ann Romney: Will Mitt Benefit? | GLORIA FELDT

Take The Lead Presented and Connected in 2014—and Wants Your Suggestions for 2015

IMG_6939-X3Understanding the Role Confidence Plays Would workplaces become more balanced and society more equitable if women exhibited more confidence? Katty Kay and Claire Shipman created a stir with their book The Confidence Code and their article, “The Confidence Gap” in The Atlantic. To continue this important conversation, we were honored to have Shipman speak to the Take The Lead community in July about how personal confidence relates to women advancing in the workplace and in society. Yes, women face very real barriers, no matter how confident we are, but leading with confidence expands our possibilities in ways that change our lives and the lives of other women. (Like this quote? Tweet it!) Did you attend this event with Shipman? What did you learn? This confidence question will surely be an ongoing conversation, so we’d love to hear your thoughts! TakeTheLead-80-X3The Solution to Feeling Stuck: Get a Coach! At Take The Lead we teach women to define their lives and careers on their own terms. But history has also told us how crucial it is to seek help when we need it. That’s why we were so excited to gather some of the best coaches we know for an event in NYC sponsored by the fabulous ALEX AND ANI. Alisa Cohn, Robyn Hatcher, Bonnie Marcus, Dana Balicki, Audrey S. Lee, Maggie Castro Stevens, and Leslie Grossman joined us to share their wisdom and generously donate hours of coaching time to attendees. See photos from the event and learn more here. 15777710358_506c524d16_o-X3Circling Up! One way we achieve leadership parity at Take The Lead is by working with women across all backgrounds, generations, and professional fields. And we’re proud to collaborate with a larger resurgent women’s movement. One way we create connections among women is through our online Take The Lead Community. If you haven’t signed up yet, please do so to network and get honest, actionable advice from other accomplished women having valuable conversations. Soon we’ll be adding a mentoring component you won’t want to miss. Gearing Up for 2015 Stay in touch with Take The Lead by signing up for our newsletter, and following us Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn. Thanks again to everyone who joined us this year and stay tuned for exciting developments in 2015! Remember! Please take a moment in the comments section to tell us what’s bugging you, highlight learning topics you want to see in our webcasts, courses, or blog, and suggest experts you admire. You can also tweet us at @takeleadwomen using the hashtag #takeleadwomen2015. If you’re moved by the work Take The Lead does to give women and men true parity across all sectors, it’s not too late to donate to enable us to Teach, Connect, and Present to more people next year. Read more about our strategy for change, Take The Lead’s 4 keys to leadership parity, here.